Not Your Average Cistory
  • Home
  • Portfolio
  • Blog
  • Reading List
  • Exhibitions
    • TRS Fight For Access

Trans Museum Studies Blog

Interpreting During A Culture War: A Review of The AAM's "Interpreting Transgender Stories In Museums and Cultural Heritage Institutions"

26/7/2023

0 Comments

 
I first became aware of the American Alliance of Museum’s Task Force for Transgender Inclusion early on in my career, and their recent document Interpreting Transgender Stories in Museums and Cultural Heritage Institutions caught my attention right away. As frequent readers of my work will know, a good deal of my research and practice on transgender museums has centred on the ways that we can tell transgender stories in new and vibrant ways that can speak to transgender lives. This document seemed perfect for someone like me to delve into and explore. Having a single resource that can help develop trans-inclusive programs would be an incredible boon to the field!
Picture
Unfortunately, I do not think this is that document, and the advice included within ranges from baffling to unintentionally problematic. I have three major issues with the document, which I will explain and discuss my alternatives after the break.
​


Read More
0 Comments

Hopping the Fence: An Historical Look At Gatekeeping and the Narratives that Helped Trans People Transition

14/4/2023

1 Comment

 
​When I was coming out in early 2017, one of the first resources I found was a zine called Mascara and Hope. Although it was aimed at trans women in the UK navigating the NHS gender clinic system, it was one of my first glimpses at how trans people have had to contort themselves in order to be given the health care they so desperately deserve. While I am lucky that my experiences getting on hormones in Toronto was no where near as infuriating as it describes, I cannot help but think back to it and other materials in the wake of the Missouri Attorney General’s emergency rule that will increase barriers to access.

Read More
1 Comment

Book Review: Before We Were Trans: A New History of Gender by Kit Heyam

16/7/2022

0 Comments

 
​For over a year now, I have had an idea for an exhibition on trans history in the back of my head. Called Gender Complexities, it would look at examples of gender expression beyond a traditional gender binary around the world. This was spurred on by Asa Johannesson and Clair Le Couteur’s article “Nonbinary Difference: Dionysus, ~~Arianna~~, and the Fictive Arts of Museum Photography”. In it, the authors use a bust of Dionysus that had previously been catalogued as Arianna to discuss how fragile our understandings and perceptions of gender can be. My goal with this exhibition was/will be (depending on if I get to design it) to expand how we think of trans history. Trans history is often viewed rather limitedly, either individuals we can definitely prove were trans or indigenous groups that white trans people will cling to as an example of prelapsarian existence, often with little care for those groups beyond their use to claim that “we have always existed”. The breadth of trans history is far broader and begging to be told.
A copy of the UK cover to
Before We Were Trans: A New History of Gender by Kit Heyam.
​If I ever do get a chance to create that exhibit, Kit Heyam’s recent book Before We Were Trans: A New History of Gender will most certainly be the first I reach for. 

Read More
0 Comments

Framing Agnes: Speaking To A Transgender Audience

28/2/2022

1 Comment

 
In the lead up to the premiere of Framing Agnes, I sought out interviews and panels for the film, thinking it might be interesting to discuss on my website. I was already excited to watch the film, but there was a sentiment that perked my interest further. Morgan M. Page, one of the writers of the documentary, mentioned that the target audience was trans people, not cisgender outsiders. My ears perked up immediately. I had come to the same conclusion about my trans museum studies work during my first exhibition, so I was very curious to see how the film handled this. My curiosity was further piqued when Jen Richards echoed the same sentiments in a different panel. In that one, Richards compared Framing Agnes to the far more straight forward Disclosure, with Agnes being much more for trans people. By the time the premiere came around, my anticipation was heightened. I am excited to say that it lived up to that high bar.

Read More
1 Comment

Book Review: The Hidden Case of Ewan Forbes And The Unwritten History of the Trans Experience By Zoe Playdon

26/1/2022

0 Comments

 
​The Hidden Case of Ewan Forbes, written by Zoe Playdon, is a semi-biography of the Scottish landowner Ewan Forbes. A trans man, Forbes had his masculine identity affirmed by a court in the late 1960s to settle an inheritance dispute. This case, which would have had significant ramifications for transgender rights around the world, but it was instead stricken from the record. The book uses Forbes’ life as a jumping off point to discuss wider movements and moments within transgender history in really fascinating ways. 
​

Read More
0 Comments

Book Review: The Shape of Sex By Leah DeVun

10/10/2021

0 Comments

 
​I believe I first found out about The Shape of Sex shortly after I had surgery earlier this year. I was immediately interested. DeVun had previously co-edited an issue of Transgender Studies Quarterly on Trans*historicities that I have referenced extensively, so I was rather excited to get my hands on The Shape of Sex. I am happy to report that it lived up to my expectations. This book, more than any I have read before, makes a strong case of transgender studies as a discipline.
​

Read More
0 Comments

How Do We Talk About Transgender History?

30/8/2021

0 Comments

 
I hate Leslie Feinberg’s Transgender Warriors. Reading it is like torture to me. It is part history book, part autobiography, but unfortunately it is still one of the few mainstream books on transgender history. Feinberg is not an historian, and it shows. The whole book serves a narrative around class conflict; the upper classes subjugated the lower classes in many ways, one of which was through destroying transgender experiences. While Clare Sears’ Arresting Dress takes a similar framework, Transgender Warriors lacks any kind of nuance. Worse yet, Feinberg will offhandedly mention aspects of transgender existence without exploring them further. It becomes incredibly frustrating to read because it is clear to the reader that there is more that could be done with the history than is being presented. It is a book full of loose ends.
​
But there is one thing I appreciate Transgender Warriors for; its broad definition of what counts as “transgender”. The definition of “transgender” has changed a lot since Feinberg wrote Transgender Warriors; at the time, it represented anyone who was “beyond-the-binary” (Bettcher). Since then, transgender has come to mean a lot of different things, from binary transgender people to being an umbrella term for the whole community (often represented as trans*). The reasons for these changes are complicated, and even I do not fully understand them. But reading something like Transgender Warriors and calling a figure like Joan of Arc transgender for existing outside the traditional gender binary; that can be very refreshing.

Read More
0 Comments

Reflecting on Transition Related Surgery: The Fight For Access

29/7/2021

0 Comments

 
​My exhibition, Transition Related Surgery: The Fight For Access, launched earlier this month. This was a culmination of 21 months of work. This exhibition served as an avenue to explore the ways in which trans history and trans stories can and should be told. Because of this, I felt it was appropriate to discuss some of the choices I made in this reflection. 

Read More
0 Comments

Dime Museums and The Exhibitionary Complex

26/3/2021

0 Comments

 
​When I think about how I describe my current career trajectory and the aim of this blog, the phrase I frequently come back to is “bridging the gap between trans studies and museum studies.” I think this really highlights what I am trying to achieve. Museum studies alone is not at the point yet where I feel it can quarrel with the very broad idea of transness on its own (just recently I found an article published last year that used a definition that misgenders trans people) and so it is frequently within the sphere of trans writing that I find relevant material. This was the case with Clare Sears’ Arresting Dress: Cross-Dressing, Law, and Fascination in Nineteenth-Century San Francisco and one section in particular.

Read More
0 Comments

Philosophy Tube, Coming Out, and Trans Curating

25/2/2021

0 Comments

 
​On January 30, Abigail Thorn, the youtuber Philosophy Tube, released a video coming out as transgender. In her video Identity: A Trans Coming Out Story, she rather poetically discussed the philosophy behind questioning one’s gender. I would recommend watching it before finishing this article. Thorn’s video caused me to revisit a lot of thoughts I have not returned to since I was questioning my own gender, today being four years since I “came out to myself”. A lot has happened in those four years so looking back on that questioning process, especially with my Museum Studies degree, produced some very surprising realizations.

Read More
0 Comments
<<Previous

    Amelia smith

    Trying to bridge the gap between transgender studies and museum studies.

    Archives

    June 2025
    November 2024
    June 2024
    November 2023
    July 2023
    April 2023
    July 2022
    June 2022
    April 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021

    Categories

    All
    Admitting Uncertainty
    American Alliance Of Museums
    Asato Ikeda
    Audience
    Book Review
    Britain
    Canada
    Clare Sears
    Clarke Institute
    Coming Out
    Crossdressing
    Culture War
    Digital Exhibition
    Dime Museums
    Documentary
    Exhibition
    Gay History
    Historic Sites
    Jennifer Tyburczy
    John Singer Sargent
    John Summers
    Julia Serano
    Kit Heyam
    Leah DeVun
    LGBT
    Mapplethorpe
    Martin Duberman
    Mary Weismantel
    Middle Ages
    Museum Of Transology
    Museum Studies
    Narrative
    NEMA
    Nuts!
    Penny Lane
    Prejudice And Pride
    Queer History
    Reflection
    San Francisco
    Sex Museums
    Sexuality
    Shape Of Sex
    Stonewall
    Tenement Museum
    Theory
    Tony Bennett
    Toronto
    Transgender
    Transgender History
    Trans Health Care
    Transition Related Surgery

    RSS Feed

      Sign up to be notified of new posts

    Subscribe to Newsletter
    Tweets by NtUrAvrgCistory
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Portfolio
  • Blog
  • Reading List
  • Exhibitions
    • TRS Fight For Access